By Sara Shepard
4.5 out of 5
From the outside Sutton Mercer couldn't seem to be happier. She has a great group of friends, a loving family, and a doting boyfriend. But looks can be deceiving. Because Sutton Mercer is actually Emma Paxton, and she is definitely not all right. Things wrong with Emma's life? One, Thayer Vega, Sutton's boyfriend, is back in town, and he's having a little trouble figuring out why Sutton isn't with him anymore. Two, Emma's mom just showed up, and her dad--check that, her grandfather--wants to keep this information secret. But is Becky a danger?? Mr. Mercer says that she's unstable, but does he even know the half of it? What if Becky was the one who killed Sutton, and then has been watching Emma, making sure she plays her roll correctly.
Yay!! I'm so excited to finally read this! This book was so good!! Emma has really stepped into Sutton's spot so well, and you get to see the repercussions of constantly pretending to be something you're not. But whenever Emmas starts to lose herself, Ethan is right there to save her. Oh Ethan!! I have always like Ethan, but I like him even more now that we have a Thayer threat. Which I would be totally fine if Emma wanted to try out Thayer for a while too! All in all, I really liked the story, and I can't wait until the next one comes out!